No Bull Real Estate
Call Us: 02 4955 2624
The case for renting over buying

The case for renting over buying

  • 30 Jun 2019
  • Jon Byrne

For a lot of Australians, buying a home is still considered the bedrock of living the Australian dream despite the rapid growth in house prices in the past few years. And for some of those people who are laser focused on buying a property, they may consider rent "dead money."

A recent report by Ernst & Young (EY), however, asks the question 'is renting really dead money?' It's a valid question, and one that many people have been contemplating as uncertainty in the housing market continues. Here, we're taking a look at the report and why, in some cases, renting can be better than buying for building wealth.

Societal views on renting
In EY's report, the team surveyed Sydney residents to get their views on whether renting was a 'waste of money.' This survey returned unsurprising results with two out of three respondents answering that they thought renting was a waste of money.

A different view on building wealth
To demonstrate that there are other ways, beyond home ownership, to build wealth, EY completed some financial modelling. This modelling compared two scenarios. The first scenario was modelled on a person buying a home with a 20 per cent deposit (80 per cent loan-to-value ratio (LVR) for the property). The other scenario was modelled on someone renting a dwelling in the same suburb, but instead of buying they bought shares in an ASX200 index fund using a margin loan (at 50 per cent LVR).

Analysed over ten years from 1994 to 2017 for 43 suburbs around Sydney, the financial modelling compared the financial position of the renter to the home owner. Over these years, the renter put their cost savings into their ASX200 index fund holdings. These cost savings were the difference between rent payments and home ownership costs (loan interest, loan principal and repairs and maintenance).

Based on the financial modelling, the renter was financially better off for 62 per cent of each 10-year period of analysis. The results, however, are better for the home owner if the ASX200 index fund investment isn't leveraged with a margin loan.

Shifting the way we think about home ownership
There are cases for and against each wealth-building scenario. EY's study demonstrates that people can build wealth without owning property; however, it does take a healthy risk appetite to put in place especially when you're exposed to the share market.

Reports like EY's also raise a critical discussion around our views on home ownership and what it means for building wealth. Home ownership is a deeply ingrained cultural norm in Australia that has stemmed from an era where society and the economy were very different from today. With research like EY's, further questions about our cultural norms around housing and building wealth are being explored.

Buying, selling, leasing for residential, commercial, industrial property, contact your local expert to buy, sell or lease today on 49552624 or www.nobullrealestate.com.au

December

06 Dec 2019 | Things to do around home these holidays

01 Dec 2019 | Mount Hutton Property Management

November

29 Nov 2019 | Buying Property with a Friend

25 Nov 2019 | Tips Every Renter Needs to Know

22 Nov 2019 | Morisset Property Management

20 Nov 2019 | Consumer Confidence is at a Four-Year Low

16 Nov 2019 | Co-Living is Providing New Living Spaces

09 Nov 2019 | Minmi Property Management

05 Nov 2019 | 0% Interest Rates and Start QE

01 Nov 2019 | Merewether Heights Property Management

October

30 Oct 2019 | Splitting Rent & Expenses with Housemates

23 Oct 2019 | Merewether Property Management

17 Oct 2019 | Mayfield West Property Management

15 Oct 2019 | Rental Market Best Affordability in 11 Years

11 Oct 2019 | Strengthen your Investment Strategy

08 Oct 2019 | 5 Steps to Get Your Rental Bond Back in Full

04 Oct 2019 | Mayfield East Property Management

02 Oct 2019 | 3 Key Steps for Property Investing Success

September

26 Sep 2019 | Mayfield Property Management

23 Sep 2019 | Is Australia headed for a 0% cash rate?

18 Sep 2019 | Maryville Property Management

16 Sep 2019 | House or apartment? Which is better?

11 Sep 2019 | Maryland Property Management

09 Sep 2019 | Top Tips for Spring Cleaning your Home

05 Sep 2019 | Lambton Property Management

03 Sep 2019 | Fragile Conditions in Construction Sector

August

30 Aug 2019 | Winter reading for the savvy investor

26 Aug 2019 | Kotara South Property Management

24 Aug 2019 | Freshen up your space in winter

20 Aug 2019 | Power of buying in good school catchments

18 Aug 2019 | Kotara Property Management

14 Aug 2019 | How to dress up a drab bathroom

12 Aug 2019 | The Junction Property Management

09 Aug 2019 | Another month, another rate cut

07 Aug 2019 | Jesmond Property Management

July

30 Jul 2019 | Islington Property Management

25 Jul 2019 | The Federal Election is over, now what?

19 Jul 2019 | The Hill Property Management

18 Jul 2019 | Multipurpose items for your home

15 Jul 2019 | Hexham Property Management

12 Jul 2019 | How to make tax time go smoothly

08 Jul 2019 | Hamilton South Property Management

06 Jul 2019 | 4 things when searching for a rental

04 Jul 2019 | ATO cracking down on deductions

02 Jul 2019 | Hamilton North Property Management

June

30 Jun 2019 | The case for renting over buying

24 Jun 2019 | Hamilton East Property Management

20 Jun 2019 | New home approvals declined in 2019

17 Jun 2019 | Hamilton Property Management

15 Jun 2019 | Turn your place into a cosy winter home

11 Jun 2019 | Georgetown Property Management

08 Jun 2019 | Regional Areas Value Declines

06 Jun 2019 | Time Spent On Property Research

03 Jun 2019 | Fletcher Property Management

May

29 May 2019 | Conversations with potential housemates

27 May 2019 | Elermore Vale Property Management

25 May 2019 | Lending to households has increased

22 May 2019 | Cooks Hill Property Management

20 May 2019 | Create more storage space in your home

13 May 2019 | 3 finance hacks investors should know

10 May 2019 | Carrington Property Management

06 May 2019 | Broadmeadow Property Management

03 May 2019 | Is it worth buying a budget property

01 May 2019 | Black Hill Property Management

April

29 Apr 2019 | Rental Vacancy Rates

23 Apr 2019 | Birmingham Gardens Property Management

17 Apr 2019 | Beresfield Property Management

16 Apr 2019 | Off Market Property Sales

11 Apr 2019 | Strong Rental Applications

08 Apr 2019 | Bar Beach Property Management

05 Apr 2019 | Increase your chances of a loan approval

03 Apr 2019 | Adamstown Heights Property Management

01 Apr 2019 | Moving into a share house

March

28 Mar 2019 | Adamstown Property Management

25 Mar 2019 | Banking Royal Commission

18 Mar 2019 | Newcastle Property Management

15 Mar 2019 | Proposed negative gearing policy

12 Mar 2019 | Seahampton Property Management

08 Mar 2019 | Gross rental yields are at a 2½ year high

04 Mar 2019 | Edgeworth Property Management

February

25 Feb 2019 | The importance of negotiation skills

20 Feb 2019 | Barnsley Property Management

14 Feb 2019 | Property market in 2019

07 Feb 2019 | Warners Bay Real Estate

January

31 Jan 2019 | Split your household bills

23 Jan 2019 | West Wallsend Real Estate

18 Jan 2019 | Fixtures and fittings in your property

17 Jan 2019 | Toronto Real Estate

11 Jan 2019 | Australian house prices in 2019

08 Jan 2019 | Speers Point Real Estate

December

18 Dec 2018 | Rathmines Real Estate

11 Dec 2018 | Killingworth Real Estate

06 Dec 2018 | Holiday reading for property investors

03 Dec 2018 | Popular areas to rent in 2018

November

30 Nov 2018 | Jesmond Real Estate

21 Nov 2018 | Getting to know your neighbourhood.

13 Nov 2018 | Islington Real Estate

09 Nov 2018 | Indicators for future growth

07 Nov 2018 | Hamilton Real Estate

02 Nov 2018 | New home construction to fall in 2019.

October

29 Oct 2018 | Fennell Bay Real Estate

25 Oct 2018 | Are you storm ready?

22 Oct 2018 | Fassifern Real Estate

15 Oct 2018 | How to keep your property cool

11 Oct 2018 | Elermore Vale Real Estate

08 Oct 2018 | Is it the right time to buy again? 

05 Oct 2018 | Cooks Hill Real Estate

02 Oct 2018 | Avoid financial pitfalls

September

26 Sep 2018 | Coal Point Real Estate

19 Sep 2018 | Get your rental bond back

10 Sep 2018 | Carrington Real Estate

06 Sep 2018 | The rise of micro-apartments

03 Sep 2018 | Cardiff Real Estate

August

31 Aug 2018 | Downsides to positive cash flow properties?

28 Aug 2018 | Callaghan Real Estate

20 Aug 2018 | Booragul Real Estate

13 Aug 2018 | How To Find A Great Housemate

03 Aug 2018 | Boolaroo Real Estate

July

27 Jul 2018 | Blackalls Park Real Estate

20 Jul 2018 | Birmingham Gardens Real Estate

12 Jul 2018 | Beresfield Real Estate

05 Jul 2018 | Awaba Real Estate

03 Jul 2018 | Broadmeadow Real Estate